Anchors and Recipes
October 11, 2026 | by Matthew Herriot
documentary Painters Painting (1973).
This is a painting from Frank Stella’s Saskatchewan series, made around 1970. If Stella hadn’t existed, and someone made this painting today, it wouldn't be a good painting.
For this work, Stella employed his signature multicolored curved bands from his Protractor series, with several changes: he enlarged their width relative to the size of the painting; he fit them into a rectangular canvas rather than a shaped one; and he allowed more of those curved bands to go off the painting’s edge rather than running parallel with the edge, contained within it. Yet, through all these changes, the work remains unmistakably a Stella. This results in a perceptual discrepancy: at once, you recognize the work as a quintessential example of his practice from this period, yet experience it as an unexpected version of that quintessence. Simply put, you know what you are looking at, but you did not expect it to look like that. In person, a perceptual discrepancy of this kind produces aesthetic surprise. The moment of perception is meaningful because it is consequential. You must revise your own understanding of what a “signature Stella” from this period is, prompting close visual attention and a fresh judgment of the work.
If someone made this painting today, outside the context of Stella’s oeuvre, it wouldn’t compel you to make a fresh judgment. Even though the painting would be different from other paintings you have seen, it wouldn’t contradict any expectation you held prior to looking at the work. After all, basically everything encountered in daily life is different—the bouquet of flowers you walk past, the train approaching your platform, the t-shirt of someone passing by. Mere difference, without the breaking of expectations, produces a reaction of indifference. While the art world has an abundance of difference, or novelty, what is exceedingly rare is encountering a painting that is deeply familiar in essence yet unexpected in its precise manifestation. That perceptual discrepancy is what makes looking at a painting feel necessary and alive.
Here’s why it’s so rare. Picture a dark green bottle of olive oil in your mind, and then imagine that the bottle changes color to bright pink. That’s no longer a bottle of olive oil. It’s something else. An artist must invent a visual feature that is so distinctive on its own that it can survive substantial formal changes without your brain making you think “that’s something else.” Many painters have distinctive work that is recognizable at a glance. Few painters have distinctive work that remains recognizable as their own despite radical formal change—such as breaking from their usual color palette, changing the painting’s surface or substrate, altering their methods of representation, or disrupting scale, density, or rhythm. Painting the same thing utterly transformed, without those radical changes making you think you’re looking at something else, is what formalist art should aspire toward because it is the precondition for aesthetic surprise.
Following this logic, aesthetic surprise requires a visual identity that is stable enough to generate expectations but concentrated in just one or two defining features, such that other formal properties remain free to transform, subverting one’s expectations across a body of work. Let’s call this type of visual feature an anchor. For instance, Stanley Whitney’s anchor is his peculiar grid with horizontal dividing bands, which is distinctive enough to identify his work on its own. This frees color and, at times, application to drastically change across works, as diverse sequences of light, dark, warm, and cool tones morph each painting into a distinct spatial arena. His practice generates surprising manifestations of the same thing again and again. Katherine Bernhardt’s anchor is her pop-cartoon motifs depicted using spray-painted outlines and fluid acrylics. Since her work’s visual identity rests in these two features alone, each painting can hold almost any organization of color and form and still read as a classic Bernhardt, opening the possibility for aesthetic surprise: you know what you are looking at, but you did not expect it to look like that.
Oil on linen, 96 x 120”
Oil on linen, 96 x 96”
Painters who do not create such an anchor attempt to make their work recognizable by combining several fixed features together, leaving fewer features available to change and meaningfully transform the work – let's call it a recipe. For example, Callum Innes’s Exposed Paintings are characterized by their bisected composition, one half black, the other half a single transparent color, made using Innes’s process of applying and removing oil paint. Only through the total configuration of these features does the painting become recognizable as Innes’s signature work. The bisected composition alone is not enough: changing his particular treatment of color or subtractive paint handling would break the precise “recipe” of features that defines his work’s visual identity, resulting in something new rather than a signature Innes transformed. From here, Innes can continue making his Exposed Paintings with small differences, or begin a new recipe from scratch for a burst of novelty. Neither produces aesthetic surprise, as the former doesn’t break our expectations of his work, and the latter would mean encountering something we have no prior expectations for. A third option is available to him: begin a new body of work using an anchor.
Some representational painters use recipes too. They can be hard to detect because every new painting depicts a new image, producing the appearance of constant change. Alexis Ralaivao, for instance, is known for various recurring motifs—usually close-ups of women’s bodies or grayscale paintings of dinner-table settings. You will see something different in every painting by Ralaivao. Yet he depicts all these different subjects using a fixed recipe of formal properties: cropped imagery, soft paint handling, uniform treatment of the whole image, and predominantly monochromatic palettes, often with one dominant hue or a pair of hues. A familiar style applied to a new subject yields novelty, not the perceptual discrepancy of encountering a familiar work made strange.
Oil on canvas, 47 ¼ x 31 ½”
Like Ralaivao, Bernhardt repeatedly applies a familiar style to new subjects. But the result is usually aesthetic surprise, not just novelty, because she regularly changes not only what she paints but how she paints, drastically varying color, spatial organization, and the pictorial abbreviations that render her subjects visible. This is possible for Bernhardt because her signature visual identity resides entirely in her pop-cartoon motifs and her application method, leaving everything else free to change in unexpected ways without breaking that identity. For a Ralaivao painting to remain a signature work, however, it must preserve many more consistent features: his habitual motifs, application method, approach to color, close cropping, and uniform image treatment. None of those features is distinctive enough to define his signature visual identity on its own, so he must rely on a combination of all of them. This leaves very few formal elements available to transform his work into a surprising manifestation of itself. When he departs from one aspect of the recipe too drastically, the painting may still look like a Ralaivao, but not his signature work. We experience something different, something new, which we have yet to build strong expectations for—preventing the perceptual discrepancy that drives aesthetic surprise.
What I am asking of painting is nothing new. Every modernist movement broke from the expected norms of its time. But, as I argued in my previous essay Temporal Formalism, which develops the historical and perceptual stakes of this argument in greater detail, the time it took for each radical break to become familiar and eventually anticipated grew shorter and shorter. By the 1970s, when Stella painted his Saskatchewan series, there were virtually no shared expectations left: art could, and still can, be anything. Without shared expectations, every work you see looks different, but difference alone is not enough to truly surprise.
The final remaining source of aesthetic surprise lies within the context of an artist’s own practice. A strong visual identity establishes the expectations that future works can subvert. This possibility is lost for artists whose visual identity relies on too many features at once, which establishes expectations only through relinquishing the capacity to break them. Formalist painters should therefore focus on inventing an anchor—one or two features that can define their practice alone—permitting radical experimentation without sacrificing their work’s recognizable identity.
You might enjoy the visual appeal of a painting’s color palette, or find personal meaning in the imagery. You might appreciate the artist’s story that led them to make the work, or the concepts behind their practice. That’s all fine. But running in parallel is another kind of meaning in painting: aesthetic surprise, activated when the visual expectations you held about a familiar body of work are broken. The painting that appears as an unexpected version of an artist’s signature work naturally compels close observation of its sensory features and their relations, as the perceptual discrepancy it creates cannot be resolved any other way. Without this vital element of formalist art, paintings will merely appear different, usually leading to indifference. We have enough different paintings. We need more aesthetic surprise.
About the Author:
Matthew Herriot is a British artist living and working in Chicago.
mattherriot.com
@matthew_herriot